(905) 441 0770 allen@allenehlert.com

Why a 3-Year Fixed Mortgage May be a Bad Choice in 2024

by | December 4, 2023

Why You Should Avoid Choosing a 3-Year Fixed Mortgage in 2024

Thinking of getting a three-year fixed mortgage in 2024? You might want to reconsider. While some people are tempted to time the market and assume that interest rates will go down, this strategy is risky and can lead to costly mistakes. In this blog post, we’ll explore why choosing a three-year fixed mortgage based on future interest rate expectations may not be a good idea.

Unreliable Market Timing

Timing the market is largely unreliable, even for experts. Trying to predict interest rate movements is a gamble that can go either way. In recent years, expectations of interest rate declines haven’t aligned with reality. It’s best to avoid making decisions based on uncertain market predictions.

Inverted Yield Curve and Higher Rates

The inverted yield curve suggests a possible recession, which could lead to higher interest rates. Currently, short-term interest rates are higher than longer-term rates, resulting in higher prices for shorter-term mortgages. Opting for a three-year fixed mortgage might mean paying a higher interest rate in the long run.

Low Payout Penalties and Flexibility

Consider choosing a lender that offers low payout penalties, allowing you to switch to a different lender if interest rates go down. This gives you the flexibility to take advantage of potentially lower rates without being locked into a higher rate for three years.

Fixed Rate Mortgages
Fixed Rate Mortgages

Focus on Lowest Interest Rate

When choosing a mortgage, focus on getting the lowest interest rate available at the time. Rather than banking on rates dropping in three years, prioritize the present. Currently, a five-year fixed mortgage is a better option compared to a variable rate or a three-year fixed mortgage.

Protecting Against Interest Rate Increases

Opting for a three-year fixed mortgage can provide protection against potential interest rate increases. If rates do go up or the economy enters a recession, you’ll have the security of a fixed rate for the initial three years. This can offer peace of mind and stability for budgeting.

Consider Professional Advice

Instead of making buying decisions based on future interest rate expectations, it’s crucial to seek professional advice. An expert can guide you through the mortgage options available and help you make an informed decision. Avoid unfamiliar options and rely on the expertise of a mortgage professional.

Choosing a three-year fixed mortgage in 2024 based on the expectation of interest rates declining is not advisable. Market timing is unreliable, and there are factors, such as an inverted yield curve and potential interest rate increases, that may work against you. Focus on the current lowest interest rates and seek professional advice to make the best decision for your financial situation.

Mortgage and Money Radio Logo
Allen Ehlert

Allen Ehlert

Allen Ehlert is a licensed mortgage agent. He has four university degrees, including two Masters degrees, and specializes in real estate finance, development, and investing. Allen Ehlert has decades of independent consulting experience for companies and governments, including the Ontario Real Estate Association, Deloitte, City of Toronto, Enbridge, and the Ministry of Finance.

Private Mortgage: Credit History

Private Mortgages Support Credit History

Ahmed and his wife, Aisha, recently immigrated to Canada from the UAE and settled in Mississauga, Ontario. Ahmed secured a high-paying job in IT, earning $120,000 per year, while Aisha works remotely as a consultant. They wanted to purchase a $750,000 townhouse but...
Who Needs a Private Mortgage

Who Needs a Private Mortgage?

Private mortgages in Canada serve as an alternative financing solution for borrowers who do not meet the strict lending criteria of traditional banks and credit unions. These loans are typically short-term, high-interest financing options that provide quick access to...
Mortgage Position

What is Mortgage Position

The mortgage landscape is layered with complexities, but one of the most fundamental concepts is the hierarchy of lien positions. Every mortgage or loan secured against a property has a designated ranking, which determines repayment priority in the event of default....
Get Organized

Getting Your Documents Together

There was a time when buying a home was as simple as flipping through a real estate magazine, picking a house, and heading to the bank with little more than a job letter and a pay stub. But today’s mortgage landscape is vastly different. Modern mortgage underwriting...
FCT_FNF

FNF & FCT: Lender’s Title Insurance

In the intricate world of mortgage financing, ensuring the security and legitimacy of property transactions is paramount. Fidelity National Financial (FNF) and First Canadian Title (FCT) play critical roles in protecting lenders, homebuyers, and financial institutions...
Lenders Dislike Seconds

Why Lenders Don’t Like Seconds

A second mortgage is a loan that is secured against a property that already has an existing mortgage. It is considered "second" because it is subordinate to the first mortgage in terms of priority—meaning that if the homeowner defaults, the first mortgage lender gets...
Lifestyle

Ontario’s Top Lifestyle Cities

Desirability and lifestyle play pivotal roles in determining real estate prices, as they directly influence a buyer's perception of value. In real estate, desirability often stems from a combination of location, community amenities, and the intrinsic charm of the...
What is Notarization

What is Notarization?

Notarization is the process of certifying the authenticity of a document, signature, or translation by a notary public—a legally authorized official. Notarization ensures that documents are legitimate, trustworthy, and legally recognized by courts, financial...
Mortgage Trigger Point

What is a Trigger Point

The "trigger rate" in the context of a mortgage, particularly a variable rate mortgage with fixed payments, is a specific interest rate at which the fixed monthly payments are no longer sufficient to cover both the interest and principal repayment. When the interest...

Collateral vs Standard Mortgage

When securing a mortgage in Canada, most borrowers focus on interest rates, amortization periods, and lender terms. However, an often-overlooked distinction—whether a mortgage is registered as a collateral charge or a standard charge—can have significant implications...